Contact Us Donate Site Guide
NARAL Pro-Choice Wisconsin
Print
NARAL Pro-Choice Wisconsin

Take Action

Join the Choice Lobby Network

Become a Roe of Our Own Post Card Captain

NARAL Pro-Choice Wisconsin Foundation's Wish List

» more action alerts

Choice Headlines

10/29/2008
ACLU of Wisconsin Activists Join the Fight Against South Dakota Abortion Ban

10/15/2008
Advocacy Group Sues Oklahoma over Unnecessary, Intrusive Abortion Law

10/15/2008
Advocacy Group Sues Oklahoma over Unnecessary, Intrusive Abortion Law

» more choice headlines

Press Releases

10/1/2008
NARAL Pro-Choice Wisconsin PAC Announces 2008 Endorsements for State Legislature

10/1/2008
Advocates Continue Asking Abortion and Birth Control Opponents - How Much Time Should Rape Victims Do?

9/29/2008
EC Protects Rape Victims

» more press releases

Emergency contraception bill stalls

Posted: 12/11/2007

by Mark Pitsch ¦ The Wisconsin State Journal ¦ 11 December 2007
 
A bill requiring Wisconsin hospitals to offer emergency contraception to rape victims will remain in limbo until next month after the Republican-led Assembly delayed a vote on the bill late Tuesday.

The delay came after a bipartisan group of lawmakers beat back attempts to let individual medical professionals and hospitals opt out of the requirement for moral or religious reasons, and to require notification of parents for girls under 16 offered the drug.

A spokesman for Assembly Speaker Mike Huebsch, R-West Salem, said the Assembly's not scheduled to start voting on bills again until next month.

Passing an emergency contraception bill without an exclusion would mean rape victims won't have to worry that they will become pregnant by their attacker, Barb Wise, a physical therapist from Chippewa Falls, said in an interview before the Assembly debate.

"Why should someone have to shop around for basic care?" said Wise, who said she received a form of emergency contraception at UW Hospital in 1972 after she was raped. "(Treatment) is time sensitive, and people are traumatized."

But Dr. John Rinke, an emergency room doctor with Community Memorial Hospital in Menomonee Falls, worries that without the amendment the bill could cause him to dispense the pill despite his personal objections.

"I don't want to have to choose between my conscience and my career," Rinke said before the debate.

Rep. Terry Musser, R-Black River Falls, a sponsor of the bill, said that wouldn't happen. The bill wouldn't require a specific person to dispense the emergency contraception, he said.

Musser said Assembly Republicans spent much of the afternoon debating in private the opt-out amendment.

"It would gut the bill," Musser said of the potential amendment.

Nine states require hospitals to provide emergency contraception to rape victims on request, according to the Guttmacher Institute of New York, which supports reproductive health rights.

Wisconsin's emergency contraception bill has the support of a wide range of groups, from the Wisconsin Coalition Against Sexual Assault to the Wisconsin Sheriffs and Deputy Sheriffs Association to the Wisconsin Nurses Association.

Pro-Life Wisconsin opposes the bill. But other groups opposing abortion rights, including the Wisconsin Catholic Conference and Wisconsin Right-to-Life, remained neutral.

Earlier this year, the Senate approved the measure by a bipartisan 27-6 vote.

An Assembly committee also backed it, but only after adding a provision allowing hospitals and individual health providers to opt out of offering the pill on moral or religious grounds. Critics said that would undermine the bill.

So Musser and Reps. Jeff Wood, R-Chippewa Falls, and Mark Pocan, D-Madison, introduced a proposal to have the Assembly vote on the original bill — with no exclusions based on conscience.

Earlier Tuesday, supporters of the measure, including Wise, greeted members of the Assembly with signs reading, among other things, "I support compassionate care."

Opponents spent the day lobbying lawmakers to vote against the bill.

Wise said she was grateful that UW Hospital provided her emergency contraception 30 years ago.

"It meant I didn't have to carry a rapist's child when I was, two days later, taking my exams for the university," Wise said. "I had other things to think about rather than whether in six weeks I'd be pregnant."

Rinke said the bill would coerce medical professionals to offer rape victims the contraception that he believes causes abortion. The pill is the equivalent of abortion because it blocks the implantation of an embryo, he said.

Home | Take Action | Issues | In Our State | News | About Us | Support Us |
Pregnant? Need Help? | Contact Us | Get E-mail Alerts | Privacy Policy

©NARAL Pro-Choice Wisconsin

©NARAL Pro-Choice Wisconsin